Craig Campbell SEO Training & Consultancy

Tutorials

SEO freelancer vs agency: which should you hire?

By Craig Campbell · 16 Nov 2026

3 min read

When you decide to get help with SEO, the next choice is who to hire: a freelancer, an independent consultant or an agency. Each can be the right fit. The best choice depends on the size of the job, your budget and how much you want to be involved.

This guide sets out the trade-offs in plain English. The example business below is fictional and illustrative only.

1. What a freelancer offers

A freelancer is one person doing the work themselves. You usually get a direct line to the person doing the work, flexible terms and often a lower cost. The trade-off is capacity: one person can only do so much, and holidays or illness can pause progress. Skills can also be narrower, such as content only or technical only.

Looking for freelancers? My list of the best Upwork alternatives compares 14 freelance sites.

2. What an agency offers

An agency has a team: account managers, technical specialists, writers and outreach staff. That brings more capacity and a wider range of skills, which suits bigger sites or campaigns that need lots of work each month. The trade-off is that you may deal with an account manager rather than the specialist, and costs are often higher to cover the team and overheads.

3. Where an independent consultant fits

A consultant sits between the two. You get senior, hands-on advice from one experienced person, who may also bring in trusted specialists when needed. This often suits businesses that want a clear strategy, an audit, training for their own team or a second opinion on their current provider. See my SEO consultant page for how I work.

4. A quick way to decide

  • Small local business, limited budget: a freelancer or consultant is often enough.
  • Large site or national campaign: an agency’s capacity may be worth the extra cost.
  • You have staff who can do the work: a consultant can set the plan and train them.
  • You are unhappy with your current provider: an independent audit helps you decide what to do next.

Example: Partick Pet Supplies, a fictional shop, hires a consultant for an audit and plan, then has its own staff write the content while the consultant reviews progress each month.

5. Questions to ask anyone you hire

  • Who will actually do the work?
  • What will you do in the first three months?
  • How will you report progress, and what will you measure?
  • How do you build links?
  • What happens if I want to leave?

Be wary of anyone who guarantees rankings or can’t explain their methods. My guide to outsourcing SEO covers more checks.

Limitations and next step

Good and bad providers exist in every group. Judge the person or team on their plan, honesty and track record, not their label. If you’d like an independent view, get in touch.

Sources and review notes

Let's work together.

Whether you need an SEO partner, a consultant, a speaker for your event or training for your team — get in touch and let's chat.

Get in touch
Get in touch