SEO competitor analysis means reviewing the pages competing for searches your business wants to answer. The aim is to find useful work, not copy a rival’s website or collect a huge spreadsheet.
Start with one service or product group. Compare the pages people actually see, then decide whether your own page needs a clearer answer, better evidence or a technical repair.
This guide uses Brightwell Accountants, a fictional Edinburgh business. All businesses, search terms, competing-page observations and decisions are illustrative only. They are not Craig’s clients, measured results or live competitor findings. Sources checked 15 November 2026.
1. Choose searches that matter to the business
Write down five searches tied to services you really offer. Include a buying task and a useful question, rather than chasing the biggest volume.
- “Small business accountant Edinburgh” asks for a suitable local provider.
- “Accountant for Edinburgh freelancers” narrows the audience.
- “What records should a UK sole trader keep?” asks for guidance, not a sales pitch.
These are fictional targets, not verified demand estimates. Use keyword research to check demand and keyword mapping to assign the right page. Reject topics outside your expertise or offer.
2. Find search competitors, not just business rivals
Check current UK results for each search. Record the date, location, device and page URL. A directory or publisher can be a search competitor even when it does not sell your service.
- Separate adverts from organic results.
- Note local results and whether the main pages are services, directories or guides.
- Compare a few relevant pages per search, not every domain a tool lists.
- Repeat important checks: results vary and one snapshot is incomplete.
Read the actual pages. A tool’s estimated traffic cannot tell you whether an answer is accurate or whether the business wins profitable enquiries.
3. Compare the answer and the next step
Use the same short checklist for each page: audience, answer, evidence, usability and next step.
- Audience: does it address the searcher’s situation?
- Answer: are scope, exclusions and common questions clear?
- Evidence: are qualifications and factual claims verifiable?
- Usability: can a phone visitor find the useful information?
- Next step: does the enquiry button match what happens next?
Do not assume that a longer page or more headings caused a ranking. Google’s people-first guidance emphasises usefulness and original value, not copying the length of competing articles.
4. Turn the comparison into three actions
Brightwell Accountants — fictional UK example; illustrative only
- Local service search: an invented competing page explains which Edinburgh businesses it serves. Brightwell’s page is vague. Action: clarify the real audience and location; do not invent offices.
- Freelancer search: an invented page explains the onboarding process. Brightwell offers the service but hides it. Action: improve the existing service page before creating another.
- Records question: invented competing guides omit a practical preparation list. Action: commission a reviewed checklist using current HMRC guidance; do not publish guessed tax advice.
Priority: clarify the commercial page first, then commission specialist-reviewed guidance. No ranking improvement or enquiry total is assumed.
5. Check technical and link gaps without copying them
Compare whether important pages are reachable, usable and logically linked. A competitor’s backlink export can suggest relevant publications, but it is incomplete and does not prove why that page ranks. Use the link building outreach guide to review suitable publications and prepare a restrained editorial pitch.
- Check your own indexability before commissioning more content.
- Link useful guides to the relevant service naturally.
- Assess potential coverage for audience relevance, not a tool score alone.
- Do not copy paid-link schemes or other tactics that violate Google’s spam policies.
Limitations and next step
You cannot see a competitor’s true sales, conversion rate or full strategy from public pages. Estimated traffic, keyword gaps and ranking snapshots are clues, not a business case or a promise.
Give each action an owner, an evidence note and a review date. Use an SEO content audit to decide what to keep or improve, then track changes in a monthly SEO report. Start with three defensible actions, not thirty copied topics.
Sources
Sources checked 15 November 2026. The workflow and fictional examples are editorial recommendations, not firsthand testing or client results.
